Anti-gay Ugandan tactic: Abusive, worthless anal exam
May 14, 2014
Colin Stewart
Colin Stewart is a 45-year journalism veteran living in Southern…
The defense team for two Ugandans charged with homosexual activity is preparing to counter any evidence produced by the prosecution from an anal exam that was conducted on one of the defendants.
Anal exams are used against LGBT people in Africa and the Middle East by officials who hope the tests will produce evidence of same-sex intercourse. Activists oppose anal exams as both unreliable and abusive or even a form of torture.
Defendants Kim Mukisa, 24, a gay man, and Jackson Mukasa, 19, a transgender woman, face the possibility of a life sentence if convicted in a trial scheduled to begin in Kampala on June 12.
Adrian Jjuuko, executive director of the Human Rights Awareness and Promotion Forum – Uganda (HRAPF), which arranged for the legal representation for Mukisa and Mukasa, said:
Anal exams are used against LGBT people in Africa and the Middle East by officials who hope the tests will produce evidence of same-sex intercourse. Activists oppose anal exams as both unreliable and abusive or even a form of torture.
Defendants Kim Mukisa, 24, a gay man, and Jackson Mukasa, 19, a transgender woman, face the possibility of a life sentence if convicted in a trial scheduled to begin in Kampala on June 12.
Adrian Jjuuko, executive director of the Human Rights Awareness and Promotion Forum – Uganda (HRAPF), which arranged for the legal representation for Mukisa and Mukasa, said:
“The state will most probably rely on character evidence and use the results of an anal exam which was done on one of the accused persons. The defence team has access to all the police statements, and is ready to challenge the charge, and the evidence if the matter comes to trial.”
Anal exams have previously aroused protests:
In 2012, the Lebanese physicians’ association denounced them as a form of torture — and as “medically and scientifically useless” in determining sexual activity.
In 2013, over defense objections, a magistrate presiding over the trial of two Zambian men accepted the testimony of a medical assistant who concluded that an anal exam showed that the men had engaged in homosexual activity.
Also in 2013, Egyptian authorities ordered anal exams of nine people arrested on homosexuality-related charges, but learned nothing from the exams. Activist/commentator Scott Long said, that the exams “are abusive and torturous, devoid of any medical value.”
In 2011, four men in Cameroon were arrested on homosexuality charges and forced to undergo anal exams. At least two of them were convicted, though results from the anal exams were worthless.
“Like most of the people prosecuted for homosexuality in Cameroon, there was no evidence against them,” said Human Rights Watch researcher Neela Ghoshal.
See the following articles for background on the Mukasa-Mukisa case:
In 2012, the Lebanese physicians’ association denounced them as a form of torture — and as “medically and scientifically useless” in determining sexual activity.
In 2013, over defense objections, a magistrate presiding over the trial of two Zambian men accepted the testimony of a medical assistant who concluded that an anal exam showed that the men had engaged in homosexual activity.
Also in 2013, Egyptian authorities ordered anal exams of nine people arrested on homosexuality-related charges, but learned nothing from the exams. Activist/commentator Scott Long said, that the exams “are abusive and torturous, devoid of any medical value.”
In 2011, four men in Cameroon were arrested on homosexuality charges and forced to undergo anal exams. At least two of them were convicted, though results from the anal exams were worthless.
“Like most of the people prosecuted for homosexuality in Cameroon, there was no evidence against them,” said Human Rights Watch researcher Neela Ghoshal.
See the following articles for background on the Mukasa-Mukisa case:
- Uganda court grants bail in gay-sex trial (May 8, 2014, 76crimes.com)
- LGBT Ugandans seek bail as prosecutors prepare trial (May 7, 2014, 76crimes.com)
- Potential life sentence for LGBT couple in Uganda (May 5, 2014, 76crimes.com)
- No bail for 2 Ugandans facing trial on gay-sex charges (April 23, 2014, 76crimes.com)
- 2 Ugandan men face trial on gay-sex charges (April 18, 2014, 76crimes.com)
- As many as 12 awaiting gay-sex trials in Uganda (April 25, 2014, 76crimes.com)
Also:
- As many as 12 awaiting gay-sex trials in Uganda (April 25, 2014, 76crimes.com)
- 94 who are in prison for being gay, 75 more awaiting trial (May 13, 2014, 76crimes.com)
Nigerians seek support of fearful Archbishop of Canterbury