Americas / Commentary

Don’t cut ties with Uganda; that’s an anti-gay trap

The Rev. Canon Dr. Kapya John Kaoma (Photo courtesy of BU.edu)

The Rev. Canon Dr. Kapya John Kaoma (Photo courtesy of BU.edu)

The Rev. Canon Kapya Kaoma, an Episcopal priest from Zambia and a project director at Political Research Associates, predicted last month that Ugandan President Yoweri Museveni would sign the Anti-Homosexuality Bill.  Now that Museveni has done so, Kaoma discusses what’s to be done now. He warns that some LGBT advocates’ calls for countries to cut diplomatic ties to Uganda is exactly what Museveni hopes will happen.


WARNING: U.S. LGBTQ Organizations Falling Into Uganda’s Anti-Homosexuality Trap

By THE REV. CANON KAPYA KAOMA

Ugandan President Yoweri Museveni (Photo courtesy of Wikimedia Commons)

Ugandan President Yoweri Museveni (Photo courtesy of Wikimedia Commons)

On February 24, the world woke up to the news that President Yoweri Museveni finally signed the anti-gay bill into law. This is despite his initial promise to President Barack Obama that he would await scientific evidence before signing the bill. Many people took that assurance as goodwill from Museveni, but I did not. On Saturday, Museveni indicated that he would deal with Russia, as opposed to nations that want to get involved in his country’s affairs — clearly pointing to U.S. President Obama’s opposition to the anti-gay bill. It is Russia, which is the cover to African countries’ actions on homosexuality.

Museveni’s actions should be understood from a political perspective. Museveni’s potential challenger is Speaker Rebecca Kadaga — whose reputation rose after her encounter with Canadian Foreign Minister John Baird in October 2012, during the 127th Inter-Parliamentary Union (IPU) Assembly in Quebec. Aside from saying that Uganda was neither a colony nor protectorate of Canada, Kadaga promised to pass the Kill the Gays Bill as a Christmas present to Ugandans. Upon her return to Uganda, Kadaga was met by hundreds of thousands of Ugandans and anti-gay pastors—celebrating her as a courageous leader.

Rebecca Kadaga, speaker of the Ugandan parliament (Photo courtesy of In2eastafrica.net)

Rebecca Kadaga, speaker of the Ugandan parliament (Photo courtesy of In2eastafrica.net)

Museveni has been looking for an opportunity to dislodge Kadaga from her prominence as a fighter of Western imperialism. His December 28 letter to Speaker Kadaga, in which he questioned the legitimacy of the bill, and her leadership, could have been intended to embarrass Kagada in Museveni’s NRM Caucus. Unfortunately, it failed. So, Museveni had no choice but to sign the bill and hit back on Western nations — just as Kadaga did.

Does this development justify the recall of the U.S. Ambassadors to Uganda and Nigeria? No. That would just create another wave of demonization of LGBTI persons. Besides, Museveni wants to use Western opposition to justify his own hold on power.

Museveni was aware that Western nations will react with rage. It is from this perspective that Museveni’s declaration of “war on the ‘homosexual lobby’ ” and his call to Ugandans to stand with him should be understood. To Museveni and most Ugandans, the “homosexual lobby” includes not only major LGBTQ rights organizations, but the United States and the European Union, which have for many years fought for the rights and dignity of LGBTQ persons on African soil.

Western nations and organizations have not fought in the way social justice-minded people have hoped—they have not stopped the arrests, or the beatings—but there is no doubt that their presence and back-room meetings with African politicians has saved LGBTQ lives from systematic persecution and, in some cases, genocides.

Jailed in Zambia for eight months on homosexuality charges, defendants James Mwape and Philip Mubiana await the end of their ongoing trial.

Jailed in Zambia for nine months on homosexuality charges, defendants James Mwape and Philip Mubiana await the end of their ongoing trial.

It is these nations and organizations that have provided safe spaces for African LGBTQ persons—even in extraordinarily homophobic countries like Nigeria, Uganda, Zambia, Zimbabwe and the Gambia—to share their plight and reorganize after their governments disband them. In Zambia and Uganda, these nations have gone beyond simple meetings with local LGBTQ activists, but are monitoring and documenting human rights abuses, flooding court rooms when LGBTQ persons appear in court, and have provided safety when African nations declare war on gays. When LGBTQ Africans lives’ are in immediate danger, it is to the U.S. and European embassies they run for safety. These nations’ open protection of sexual minorities in Africa has resulted in charges of “promoting homosexuality in Africa” by both religious and political leaders.

Honestly, had it not been for the presence of the U.S. and European embassies, African gays would have been massacred years ago, without any fear of consequences. For LGBTQ organizations to now demand they pull out of Uganda perilously compromises the lives of LGBTQ persons—who will not have anyone to turn to for safety, and strip our ability to monitor persecution.
Knowing that most people don’t understand the pan-African ethics of solidarity, how African nations perceive Western response to Uganda will have effects across the continent, from Kenya to Algeria to Ethiopia.

We need Western nations’ presence in the fight against the criminalization of LGBTQ persons in Africa more than American human rights activists. Recalling the U.S. ambassador for a while also will not help much. It will not just be misunderstood by African media but also confirm the false claim that Western nations are in Uganda for one purpose—to recruit young people into homosexuality. This perception will increase the negative attitudes against LGBTQ persons in Uganda. It is time to realize that African LGBTQ people are not all activists—most of them exist without public faces in villages and shanty compounds.

Russian President Vladimir Putin (Photo courtesy of WIkimedia Commons)

Russian President Vladimir Putin (Photo courtesy of WIkimedia Commons)

Museveni’s preference of Russia over the Western nation should be understood in the context of the neo-colonial politics. Uganda is not the first country to pass this Anti-Homosexuality Bill banning advocacy for LGBTQ issues—Russia was first. Nigeria followed, and many more nations are still to follow. From now on, how we deal with Russia will affect African nations’ perceptions of Western involvement in sexual politics. As long as Russia maintains its anti-gay laws, any criticisms of Uganda or Nigeria will be seen as neo-colonial meddling — which makes even vicious dictators (like Robert Mugabe of Zimbabwe) become heroes in the eyes of the African people.

African nations are sensitive to neo-colonial and imperialistic attitudes of the West—hence they are likely to side with Museveni. The move will only make Museveni a hero not just among Ugandans, but also among his African allies— precisely what he is hoping for after watching his political power fade in recent years. If the West attacks him, or leaves the country, Museveni will have free rein to rule as the dictator he wants to be.

So what is the way forward?

David Bahati (Photo courtesy of NTV)

Ugandan member of parliament David Bahati, who first proposed the Anti-Homosexuality Bill in 2009. (Photo courtesy of NTV)

I understand that this new development demands drastic diplomatic actions, but cutting the aid or diplomatic ties with Uganda should not be one of them. Aside from boosting the political power and credibility of leaders like Museveni, David Bahati, and Martin Ssempa — opening the door for African nations to expand further anti-LGBTQ laws — such actions will have repercussions on the poor and beyond Uganda. Sanctions against Uganda or withdrawal of aid will hurt the poor and not Museveni and his government.

In this regard, there is need to put measures in place that will affect Museveni and all the anti-gay politicians and religious leaders. Selective sanctions—whereby specific anti-gay individuals are sanctioned from traveling and as well as visiting Europe — can have better effects than sanctioning the entire nation. Targeted sanctioned worked in Zimbabwe and I believe can also work in Uganda.

Rick Warren, pastor of Saddleback Church (Photo courtesy of Wikimedia Commons)

Rick Warren, pastor of Saddleback Church (Photo courtesy of Wikimedia Commons)

Moreover, African homophobia is promoted and propelled by religion. In Uganda, Christian leaders (paid for and encouraged by American evangelicals) have been demanding the bill for years, and pushing their followers to vote for the lawmakers who support it. Politicians will always be politicians—they are always looking for votes. In his attempt to win the Evangelical votes in 2008, then-presidential candidate Barack Obama disagreed with same-sex marriage in a debate moderated by Pastor Rick Warren—one of the very same U.S. evangelicals who worked with anti-gay pastors in Uganda.

But to think that such dynamics only work in American politics is naïve at best, and dangerous, careless, and deadly at worst. Museveni needs votes to remain in power.

So the answer to Uganda’s anti-gay law lies in the primarily Christian religious leaders. We should demand that Pope Francis speak directly to President Museveni and Speaker Rebecca Kadaga, and urge Ugandan Roman Catholics to proclaim his already-stated opposition to any law criminalizing LGBTQ persons. U.S. breakaway Episcopalian (Anglican), and Evangelical/Pentecostal leaders should equally speak to their friends in Uganda about the dignity and fundamental human rights of sexual minorities.

And the American people must demand an end to the constant flow of exportation of homophobia from U.S. evangelicals like Scott Lively, Lou Engle, and Rick Warren to Ugandan pastors and politicians.

A native of Zambia, Rev. Canon Kapya Kaoma is the author of Colonizing African Values and Globalizing the Culture Wars.

 

Enhanced by Zemanta

28 thoughts on “Don’t cut ties with Uganda; that’s an anti-gay trap

  1. Rev. Kaoma is absolutely correct. His call should be heeded. I would like to add that in addition to calling on sympathetic religious leaders to pressure government leaders in Uganda, especially the Catholic sector, they should be doing this across Africa. In particular Cameroon, where I have landed to take on a practical project, the Catholic hierarchy–including Pope Francis–have done nothing to denounce the killings, office ransacking, harassment of LGBTQI people. And furthermore, we internationalists need to give financial and physical support–as traditionally the “accompaniment” movements have done. Please consider going to our Indiegogo campaign at http://www.indiegogo.com/projects/651675/emal/541524 (Thanks to Colin Stewart for first announcing this!) Go to our Website: camef.weebly.com to learn more and help strengthen the local activists. I am volunteer manager of the Indiegogo campaign for CAMEF, Cameroonian LGBTQI service agency: HIV/AIDS prevention, human rights advocacy, etc. The center was closed in Dec. with death threats. Help us to reopen–the staff is willing to risk their lives. Yeah, the religious lobby will condemn them as pawns of the Wester homosexual lobby. But this is no different from the days in Central America when the freedom fighters were accused of being communists and we stood by their side as “foreign” accompaniers. Thanks!

    Like

  2. Aide to bolster a government that is persecuting its citizens are incompatible tactics.

    Meanwhile, we in the US are to “demand” that the Pope speak with the ignorant Museveni? . . . and also “demand” that evangelical propaganda not be exported from the US? The notion of travel restrictions is impractical, at best, though not ss bad as the silly idea that “breakaway” Anglicans in the US can have leverage in Uganda to protect gay men and women. I am thrilled to hear these strategies “worked” in Zimbabwe, since everyone knows that Mugabe is quaking and in flight, despite all contrary reports.

    No thanks to this fantasy. We will work instead to curtail tourism and aide, since the ignornant Museveni has invited us to do so. It would be rude to refuse.

    Like

  3. Pingback: Uganda opposition takes aim at anti-gay law | 76 CRIMES

  4. Using politics to divert attention is nothing new. Politicians are limited and they do what they are comfortable at doing, deceive and bribe. I do not think the lukewarm suggestions you mentioned will have any lasting and positive effect either. A slap on the wrist is like soft porn…pretty but pretty much ineffective. Fight fire with fire. Here are some suggestions
    1. Appoint an openly gay Ambassador to Uganda. The horror to deal with such an individual should be traumatic enough for even satan himself Museveni.
    2. Surgically point your relief funds to things that support human rights in Uganda. Money always hit hard. Human Rights equals aid. Measure everything on Human rights.
    3. The church are the biggest hypocrites in this fiasco. Leave them out completely and shut them down slowly but surely when they seek assistance in the name of the church. Challenge their records on human rights and hold them accountable.
    4. Reduce Visa allocations, scrutinize ministers who supported the bill and deny them travelling rights to the US, they will make noise but it will hurt.
    5. Secretly motivate but publicly support the local LGBT organization and ensure they have resources to challenge laws and actions that deny their human rights.

    This list is not complete but the idea is to use human rights as the theme for moving forward in Uganda. It is beyond my basic understanding that a country coming from an abuse of their human rights can now inflict such harsh and backward laws in the name of religion. But then religion has always been the ascorbic acid in every international problem. Religion is also what is preventing LGBT advocates from killing the haters.

    Like

  5. Pingback: Museveni’s politics & Uganda’s anti-homosexuality trap

  6. Pingback: 9 moves to roll back Uganda’s anti-gay law | 76 CRIMES

  7. Pingback: 9 moves to roll back Uganda’s anti-gay law | MasterAdrian's Weblog

  8. Pingback: Whoopi Goldberg has a message for Nigeria, Uganda | 76 CRIMES

  9. Pingback: Uganda: Canny political ploy sets stage for gay deaths | 76 CRIMES

  10. Pingback: Monday Music: Zero Discrimination | Border Crossings

  11. Pingback: LGBT Ugandans: Here’s how you can help us | 76 CRIMES

  12. Pingback: Europe targets anti-gay laws in Uganda, Nigeria | 76 CRIMES

  13. Pingback: Europe targets anti-gay laws in Uganda, Nigeria | MasterAdrian's Weblog

  14. Pingback: Ugandan Antihomosexuality Law | Blount Center

  15. Pingback: 4 steps U.S. is taking to counter Uganda’s anti-gay law | 76 CRIMES

  16. Pingback: Uganda kids ask: Why do Christians cheer over jail for gays? | 76 CRIMES

  17. Pingback: As activists advise, no U.K. travel ban on anti-gay Ugandans | 76 CRIMES

  18. Pingback: Why African leaders attack gays; is gay genocide next? | 76 CRIMES

  19. Pingback: ‘Winning the War’ for Marriage Equality? | Consider the Tea Cosy

  20. Pingback: ‘God Loves Uganda’ on TV, DVD today in the U.S. | 76 CRIMES

  21. Pingback: Ugandan activists to U.S.: Thanks for heeding our advice | 76 CRIMES

  22. Pingback: Germany blocks Ugandans’ trip to safety seminar | 76 CRIMES

  23. Pingback: U.S. vs. ‘Dictators’ Club’ of anti-gay African strongmen | 76 CRIMES

  24. Pingback: Researcher: Museveni outsmarted US LGBTQ activists | 76 CRIMES

  25. Pingback: Uganda’s anti-gay bill will return: Soon or pretty soon? | 76 CRIMES

  26. Pingback: 2 low-risk ways to seek LGBT rights in Africa | 76 CRIMES

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s