Rewriting the anti-gay history of Rick Warren in Uganda
Colin Stewart is a 45-year journalism veteran living in Southern…
Rick Warren, pastor of the Saddleback megachurch, traveled to Uganda in 2008 and declared that homosexuality is not a natural way of life and thus is not a human right. The next year, the anti-gay bill that became this year’s Anti-Homosexuality Law was first introduced in Uganda’s parliament. In this commentary, Eric Ethington, communication director at Political Research Associates in Massachusetts, discusses the recent attempts by Warren and Pastor Scott Lively to distance themselves from their previous statements, now that the harsh law has been enacted.
By ERIC ETHINGTON
As a communications person myself, I can really appreciate a good PR campaign, and the best I’ve seen in a long time is the new effort by U.S. right-wing evangelicals to completely whitewash their own history of involvement with Uganda’s Anti-Homosexuality Law.
For the last five years, human rights advocates around the world been discussing how U.S. conservative figures were integrally involved in the creation of the Anti-Homosexuality Bill (originally called the “Kill the Gays Bill”). Vast amounts of research have been produced on the involvement of conservatives such as Rick Warren (who posted a YouTube video supporting California’s Prop 8 only to later take it down and deny it ever happened), and hours of undercover footage were taken of Scott Lively (famous for claiming the Nazi Party was really a gay club in his book The Pink Swastika) in Kampala, Uganda, advocating the bill’s creation with local political and religious leaders.
As evidence of their involvement has spread throughout the U.S., the public’s sentiment on these characters’ involvement has soured considerably. This was exacerbated when, last month, Uganda President Yoweri Museveni signed the Anti-Homosexuality Bill into law, ascribing life-in-prison sentences to LGBTQ people in the African nation and criminalizing advocacy of homosexuality.
The American public is finally taking notice. Story after story in major media outlets (The Guardian, Real News Network, The Rachel Maddow Show, and the National Journal in just the last few weeks) is running about these right-wing evangelicals’ involvement, and the millions of dollars they’ve poured into Uganda, Nigeria, Russia, and elsewhere in carefully crafted campaigns to train local pastors and political leaders how to use culture wars-talking points for an all-out attack on LGBTQ people.
So if you were a right-wing public figure, and all of a sudden found yourself standing alone, staring down the barrel of public anger over your past work, what would you do?
For most public figures, it would be a career-ending disaster. But when you’ve got the money, the personnel, and a stellar PR team, you just might be able to convince the rest of us of a simple little lie: They were against the law in the first place.
The process of turning someone who claims “gay = Nazi” and that “equal rights = condoning pedophilia” into a “moderate” is quite the sight to behold.
Step 1: Float the New Idea
In an interview on NPR’s “Tell Me More” program, Scott Lively wasted no time distancing himself from the criminalization measures in the Anti-Homosexuality Bill. Almost before host Michel Martin could finish introducing him, Lively jumped in with, “I have mixed feelings about the bill. I support the provisions that increase penalties for homosexual abuse of children and intentional spreading of AIDS through sodomy. But I think the other provisions are too harsh, and I don’t support those and I wish they’d gone in a different direction.”
Quite the change from the Scott Lively of 2009, who wrote a blog post while in Uganda where he admitted meeting with local lawmakers, warning Ugandans “how bad things would be” if it was not illegal to be an LGBTQ person, and that his campaign to enact legislation further persecuting sexual minorities was “a nuclear bomb against the ‘gay’ agenda in Uganda.” He concluded, “I pray that this, and the predictions, are true.”
Step 2: Create a New Image
For the last several years, Pastor Rick Warren has been successfully advancing his media blitz to get people talking about anything other than his stance on homosexuality. In December of last year, he was featured in TIME Magazine talking about his new weight-loss plan. This same story has been pushed hard by Warren’s PR team, resulting in features in Parade Magazine and NPR—none of which mentioned his flip-flop on Prop 8, or his involvement with the Anti-Homosexuality Bill in Uganda.
Step 3: Strategically Place Reinforcements of Your Talking Points
Following the NPR story with Lively, a new article surfaced on the Religious News Service, expertly titled “U.S. evangelicals on the defense over Uganda’s Anti-Homosexuality Act.”
Staging the piece as a journalistic interview, author Sarah Pulliam Bailey basically transcribes a press release from Scott Lively and Rick Warren, disavowing themselves of their involvement:
California megachurch pastor Rick Warren, too, posted on his Facebook page on Sunday (March 2) denying allegations that he ever supported the Uganda bill….
Scott Lively, a Massachusetts pastor and head of Abiding Truth Ministries, said that he is not responsible for the bill.
“It’s a very insulting argument, that somehow an American evangelical pastor is so powerful that I’ve overwhelmed the intelligence of an entire government and turned them out to do my will,” Lively said. “The Ugandans knew what they wanted to hear.”
He said he does not support the bill in its final form.
Never mind that Lively himself has admitted on several occasions that he had seen and reviewed the original “Kill the Gays Bill” before it had been released to the public. Despite the ample evidence of Lively and Warren’s involvement in Uganda, none of it is mentioned. There isn’t even a hint at what pro-human rights groups have found in their research.
Step 4: Spread the Word
Now that they’ve gotten their press release printed as if it were an accredited journalistic account, the right-wing PR campaign can push to get mainstream outlets to reprint. The whitewashed article has been republished not only on small sites like Spokane Faith & Values, but on major outlets like The Washington Post.
As is typical with controversial and nuanced stories, the simple talking points are much easier to publish. Why bother researching what these right-wing evangelicals have said and done beyond U.S. borders, when they’re willing to tell American media a completely different—and significantly more palatable—story on camera?
The Fatal Flaw
This massive PR campaign has only made one mistake so far, but it’s a big one. Rick Warren has, by far, been the most successful at misleading the public into thinking he’s a moderate. He’s been at it for years. If the campaign had aimed to only wash Warren’s hands of Ugandan LGBTQ blood, it would probably succeed with flying colors. But the efforts have been ambitious than that.
The inclusion of Scott Lively throws the door wide open for the public to see this PR stunt for what it is. While few people other than researchers on the ground have seen Warren at work in Africa—partnering with local anti-gay clergy and feeding them the funds necessary to push through the Anti-Homosexuality Bill—plenty of people have heard Scott Lively on air or in his writings comparing LGBTQ people to rapists and pedophiles.
Plenty of people have seen undercover videos from Rev. Dr. Kapya Kaoma of Scott Lively in Uganda explaining that if they don’t enact anti-gay legislation then gays from America will come and recruit their children. And plenty of people have seen the videos of Scott Lively on Ugandan TV with the vehemently anti-gay Pastor Martin Ssempa, saying that Uganda needed to enact the Anti-Homosexuality Law and criminalize LGBTQ people in order to save children from being “recruited.”
There’s no question of right-wing evangelical involvement in Uganda’s anti-gay legislation. The work has been verified and fact-checked by researchers around the globe, organizations like Amnesty International, and outlets such as the New York Times. There’s a reason a court refused to throw out the case against Scott Lively for crimes against humanity.
It’s not just human rights advocates who are shocked by the turnabout from these conservatives. The anti-gay clergy in Uganda they’ve spent years training are shocked as well. Pastor Martin Ssempa was so surprised he published a letter addressed to Rick Warren, asking why he was changing his story [after Warren published a video opposing the Anti-Homosexuality Bill in 2009].
When you came to Uganda on Thursday, 27 March 2008, and expressed support to the Church of Uganda’s boycott of the pro-homosexual church of England, you stated; “The Church of England is wrong, and I support the Church of Uganda”. You are further remembered to say, “homosexuality is not a natural way of life and thus (it’s) not a human right. We shall not tolerate this aspect at all”.
Good PR work has a tendency to override facts. Tell people that something didn’t happen enough times, and eventually they’ll start to believe it. It’s up to us to tell the truth louder and more often.
This commentary was originally published by Political Research Associates as “Scott Lively & Rick Warren: The PR Campaign to Whitewash the Right’s Anti-Gay Uganda History.” It is reprinted here by permission.
Reblogged this on Embakasi Reloaded.
Twisted story, not a word of truth. Nazi style of propaganda. Mister misinformation.
Apparently you’re saying that there’s “not a word of truth” in the statements and comments of anti-homosexuality campaigners whose positions and statements (with links from this story) are the basis of the points that this commentary makes.
— Colin Stewart, editor of this blog
It’s very easy to accuse someone of lying, much harder to prove. If you have *facts* and *evidence* rather than just accusations, how about showing them. Colin cited his sources, how about you cite yours?
Oh, shut ***** up. You and the homophobic *****s who troll these message boards are the only Nazis here.
THE MOST FAMOUS HOMOSEXUALS OF THE HISTORY
1. The Man Prague (5000 A.C.)
2. Sappho of Mytilene (600 A.C. – B.C.) Greek poet
3. Socrates (470-399 A.C. – B.C.) Greek philosopher
4. Plato (427-347 A.C. – B.C.) Greek philosopher
5. Alexander the Great (356-323 A.C. – B.C.) King of Macedonia
6. Wu (140-87 A.C. – B.C.) Chinese Emperor
7. Julius Caesar (100-44 A.C. – B.C.) Roman Emperor
8. Adriano (76-138 D.C.) Roman Emperor
9. Augustine of Hippo (354-430) Holy and Father the Catholic Church
10. Benedict IX (1012-1056) Pope
11. Richard the Lionheart (1157-1199) English king and Crusader
12. Eduard II (1254-1327) English king
13. Leonardo da Vinci (1452-1519) Renaissance artist, inventor and Italian scientist
14. Michalengo Buonarrotti (1475-1564) Architect, sculptor and painter Italian
15. Montezuma II (1480-1520) Aztec emperor
16. Julius III (1487-1555) Pope
17. Ieyasu Tokugawa (1542-1616) Japanese Shogun founder of the Edo Shogunate
18. John Alexander Normandy (1545-1640) French journalist and poet
19. Sir Francis Bacon (1561-1626) British statesman
20. Christopher Marlowe (1564-1593) English poet and playwright
21. William Shakespeare (1564-1616) Playwright, poet and English actor
22. Christina Alexandra (1626-1689) Swedish queen
23. Philippe of Orleans (1640-1701) French Prince of Bourbon Dynasty
24. Peter the Great (1672-1725) Tsar of All Russia
25. Frederick the Great (1712-1786) King of Prussia and military leader
26. Madame de Staël (1766-1817) French writer and intellectual
27. Lord Byron (1788-1824) British poet
28. Hans Christian Andersen (1805-1875) Danish poet and writer
29. Margaret Fuller (1810-1850) Euro-American writer and journalist
30. Henry David Thoreau (1817-1862) Euro-American philosopher and poet
31. Herman Melville (1819-1891) Euro-American writer
32. Walt Whitman (1819-1892) Euro-American poet
33. Piotr Ilich Tchaikovsky (1840-1893) Russian composer
34. Paul Verlaine (1844-1896) French poet
35. Edward Carpenter (1844-1929) British author
36. Chief Crazy Horse (Tashunca Witko) (1849-1877) Chief tribe Oglala Sioux Chief
37. Oscar Wilde (1854-1900) English writer and playwright
38. Ethel Smyth (1858-1944) Songwriter and English artist
39. Sir Alfred Douglas (1870-1945) English writer and poet
40. Marcel Proust (1871-1922) French writer
41. Sergei Diaghileff (1872-1929) Russian Ballet businessman
42. Willa Cather (1873-1947) Euro-American writer
43. Sidonie Gabrielle Colette (1873-1954) French writer
44. Gertrude Stein (1874-1946) American writer and poet
45. William Somerset Maugham (1874-1965) British writer and playwright
46. Alice Babette Toklas (1877-1967) Euro-American writer
47. Edward Morgan Forster (1879-1970) British Writer
48. Virginia Woolf (1882-1941) Novelist, essayist and British writer
49. John Maynard Keynes (1883-1946) British economist and Nobel Prize
50. Ernst Röhm (1887-1934) German Nazi Military
51. Thomas Edward Lawrence -Lawrence of Arabia- (1888-1935) British soldier
52. Gabriela Mistral (1889-1957) Poet, diplomat, and feminist pedagogy Chilean
53. Jean Cocteau (1889-1963) French naturalist and writer
54. Vaslav Nijinsky (1890-1950) Russian ballet dancer
55. Vita Sackville-West (1892-1962) British writer
56. Cole Porter (1893-1964) Euro-American composer
57. Bessie Smith (1894-1937) American black singer
58. Federico García Lorca (1898-1936) Poet, playwright and prose writer Spanish
59. Marlene Dietrich (1901-1992) German actress and singer
60. Marguerite Yourcenar (1903-1987) Belgian-American british writer
61. Salvador Novo (1904-1974) Poet, essayist, playwright and Mexican historian
62. Christopher Isherwood (1904-1986) British author and writer
63. Greta Garbo (1905-1990) Swedish nationalized American actress
64. Frieda Kahlo (1907-1964) Mexican artist and Activist
65. Wystan Hugh Auden (1907-1973) Writer and poet
66. Simone de Beauvoir (1908-1986) Writer, teacher and French philosopher
67. Bayard Rustin (1910-87) American Human Rights activist
68. Alan Turing (1912-1954) British mathematician
69. Tennessee Williams (1914-1983) Euro-American playwright
70. Chavela Vargas (1919-2012) Mexican singer
71. Pier Paolo Pasolini (1922-1975) Writer, poet and Italian film director
72. Truman Capote (1924-1984) Euro-American author
73. James Baldwin (1924-1987) Novelist, essayist, playwright, poet and social critic
74. Gore Vidal (1925- ) Euro-American writer
75. Andy Warhol (1928- ) Plastic artist and American filmmaker
76. Harvey Milk (1930-1978) Euro-American political
77. Andy Warhol (1930-1987) Euro-American Pop Artist
78. Audre Lorde (1934-1992) African-American writer and activist
79. Alejandra Pizarnik (1936-1972) Argentina poet
80. Rudolf Nureyev (1938-1993) Russian dancer
81. Ian Mckellen (1939- ) British actor of stage and screen
82. Antonio Arbulú Neira (1944- ) Peruvian psychologist
83. Freddie Mercury (1946-1991) Pop British singer/songwriter/musician
84. Elton John (1947- ) British Singer/songwriter/musican, singer
85. Pedro Almodovar (1949- ) Film director, screenwriter and producer Spanish
86. Juan Gabriel (1950- ) Mexican singer and composer
87. Janis Ian (1951- ) Euro-American Singer/songwriter/musician
88. John Travolta (1954- ) Actor, singer, dancer and pilot American aviator
89. Nathan Lane (1956- ) Euro-American actor
90. Martina Navratilova (1956- ) Czech tennis champion
91. Miguel Bosé (1956- ) Spanish actor and singer
92. Ellen Degeneres (1958- ) Euro-American Comedian/actor
93. George Alan O’Dowd (1961- ) Singer, musician and British disc jockey
94. Melissa Etheridge (1961- ) Euro-American Singer/songwriter/musician
95. Tom Cruise (1962- ) American Actor
96. Alan Cumming (1965- ) British Actor
97. Ricardo Fort (1968-2013) Singer, actor and producing Argentinian
98. Ricky Martin (1971- ) Singer, songwriter, actor and Puerto Rican writer
99. Nein Patrick Harris (1973- ) Actor, singer and the American director
100. Leonardo di Caprio (1974- ) Actor and producer of American cinema
101. Cristian Castro (1974- ) Singer, actor and Mexican composer
102. Pablo Ruiz (1975- ) Argentine singer
103. Emiliano Rafael Boscatto (1981- ) Conductor argentine television
104. Cristiano Ronaldo dos Santos Aveiro (1985- ) Portuguese footballer