Signs of Caribbean progress for Catholics, LGBT rights

Location of Dominica in the Caribbean

Location of Dominica in the Caribbean (Photo credit: Wikipedia)

Congrats to the new Dominican LGBT group Minority Rights Dominica (MiriDom) and their leader, Daryl Philip, for continuing a robust discussion on human rights for LGBT on the island.

Some may remember that Dominica made the headlines when two gay Americans were arrested for sex on the balcony of their cruise ship.

MiriDom is localizing the issue of human rights for LGBT through an innovative approach of using the Catholic church to call for decriminalization. Dominicans are overwhelmingly Catholic.

MiriDom also has an ongoing poster campaign, supported by AIDS-Free World, which calls for respect of human rights for all Dominicans. These posters are placed in local watering holes, etc. and have generated a good amount of discussion on what human rights means.

In today’s Dominica News article on MiriDom, the group stated:

We were most impressed with the Bishop’s statement that ‘The Catholic Church maintains that free sexual acts between adult persons must not be treated as crimes to be punished by civil authorities’ as this addresses MiriDom’s concerns.

The Bishop clarified the Catholic Church’s position on the criminalization of same sex intimacy among consenting adults by stating: ‘I wish to make it clear that the Catholic Church in Dominica adheres to the call of the Holy See ‘to condemn all forms of violence against homosexual persons as well as to urge all States to take necessary measures to put an end to all criminal penalties against them’.

It is now clear that one of the oldest and the largest religious denominations in Dominica – and a major contributor to social and educational systems in Dominica – would support an end to criminal penalties against homosexuals.

The article added, “MiriDom says it looks forward to further fruitful discussions with the Bishop on the matter.”

Related articles
Posted in Americas, Anti-LGBT laws and legislation, Faith and religion, Positive steps | Tagged , , , , , | Leave a comment

Catholic bishop in Dominica: End anti-homosexuality laws

Bishop Gabriel Malzaire

Bishop Gabriel Malzaire

Bishop Gabriel Malzaire, the head of the Roman Catholic Church in Dominica, has called for the elimination of criminal penalties for homosexuality and an end to “all forms of violence” against LGBT people.

Malzaire’s position, he stated in a Dominica News commentary, is consistent with the Catholic Church’s overall position:

I wish to make it clear that the Catholic Church in Dominica adheres to the call of the Holy See in its statement to the 63rd session of the General Assembly of the United Nations on the Declaration of Human Rights, sexual orientation and gender identity, “to condemn all forms of violence against homosexual persons as well as to urge all States to take necessary measures to put an end to all criminal penalties against them. …

The Catholic Church maintains that free sexual acts between adult persons must not be treated as crimes to be punished by civil authorities.

Dominica is one of several Caribbean countries where homosexual activity is a criminal offense. The anti-homosexuality law provides for prison sentences of up to 10 years for consensual same-sex relations.

Malzaire’s statement came in response to a statement by the LGBT rights group Minority Rights Dominica, which complained that the church had not made its position clear about that law.

Two men on a gay cruise were arrested in Dominica in March 2012 after police were told they were seen engaging in sex on board their cruise ship. They were released after pleading guilty to indecent exposure.

Malzaire emphasized his support of other Roman Catholic doctrines such as opposition to (though not criminalization of):

  • Same-sex marriage.
  • Adoption of children by same-sex couples.
  • Homosexual activity.  Malzaire said that, “according to Holy Scriptures, [it] is among many wrongs which, if not controlled, can lead to spiritual death. Among these are adultery, fornication, orgies, calumny, deep seated hatred, and the like (cf. Rom 13:13; Gal 5:16-21).”
  • The use of the phrase “sexual orientation and gender identity.”  Malzaire said regarding the U.N. Declaration of Human Rights, “The Vatican specifically objected to the declaration’s use of the term sexual orientation and gender identity, which it said had no established meaning in international law.”

For more information, read his full commentary: “Decriminalization of homosexuality – what it means for the Catholic Church in Dominica.”

Posted in Americas, Anti-LGBT laws and legislation, Positive steps | Tagged | 1 Comment

Court blocks Ukraine’s first-ever gay pride rally

Ukraine's location in Europe

Ukraine’s location in Europe

A court in Kiev has ruled against plans for Ukraine’s first gay-pride demonstration.

A district court judge today found in favor of city authorities, who argued against approving the rally, based on fears that it would lead to violence and could disturb annual Kiev Day celebrations.

Last year, plans for a gay pride parade were dropped after police said they could not protect marchers and one of the organizers was beaten by an anti-gay mob.

LGBT rights are a hot topic in Ukraine. The parliament is  considering a ban on “gay propaganda” as well as a proposed antidiscrimination law that would apply to sexual minorities.

Posted in Europe, Harassment | Tagged , , , , | Leave a comment

Zambia: No bail for couple on trial for gay sex

Family members give moral support to Phil Mubiyana and James Mwape in their jail cell.

Family members give moral support to Phil Mubiyana and James Mwape in jail cell.

AllAfrica reports:

Two men in Kapiri Mposhi arrested for allegedly being in a homosexual relationship have been denied bail by a Kapiri Mposhi magistrate’s court on the basis that they may commit the same crime if released.

The two men, both aged 21, had allegedly been in a same-sex ‘marriage’ until members of the public became suspicious of the way they postured themselves, suggesting intimacy.

Scores of residents yesterday turned up to see the two men as others mocked them. …

Defence lawyers, William Ngwira and Bwalya Mubanga from SBN practitioners, applied for bail but the State objected on the basis that the two accused persons could commit the same offence again.

In rejecting the bail application, the magistrate said the accused persons may also interfere with key witnesses considering that one of them was staying with his sister and brother who are witnesses in the matter.

Earlier, Mr Ngwira applied to the court to adjourn the case in order for him to make submissions on constitutional issues.

The court has set June 5, 2013 as the date for ruling over the constitutional issues.

For more information, read the full story, entitled “Zambia: Kapiri ‘Gay’ Couple Denied Bail.” Also is the related articles from this blog, listed below.

Posted in Africa (Sub Saharan), Trials / punishments | Tagged , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Campus Crusade for Christ harms LGBTs in Ethiopia

In the wake of recent news that anti-gay Ethiopians are seeking passage of a death penalty of homosexuals, the LGBT rights group Truth Wins Out issued this statement about the role that Campus Crusade for Christ played in inciting anti-gay sentiment in Africa, especially Ethiopia:

High-Ranking Campus Crusade Officials Led Conference Where Ethiopian Activist Declared Africa Would Become A ‘Graveyard For Homosexuality’

Seyoum Antonios (Photo courtesy of Rainbow Ethiopia)

Seyoum Antonios (Photo courtesy of Rainbow Ethiopia)

In January of this year, Campus Crusade For Christ sponsored a conference called Pamoja 3, bringing together two thousand students and professionals in Lagos, Nigeria, as part of their mission to evangelize Africa. Far from being a fringe event, the conference was led by two high-ranking vice presidents in the Campus Crusade international organization, Bekele Shanko and Dela Adedevoh.

Featured speaker Dr. Seyoum Antonios, the head of United For Life Ethiopia, and who is the ringleader of a movement seeking to legislate the death penalty for homosexuality in that nation, spread false, fear-mongering rhetoric about LGBT people, serving to create moral panic and outrage among those in the audience.

Pamoja Africa logoAntonios claimed, among other things, that seventy percent of gay men have “fecal sex,” which involves ingesting large amounts of feces; that thirty-three percent of gay men are pedophiles, and that gay couples are coming to Africa to “steal their children” and turn them into homosexuals; that homosexuality has come to Africa “to kill us,” and thus must be eradicated; that gays are fifteen times more likely to be murderers; and that Africans should reject aid from Western organizations that are “trying” to infiltrate their continent with the homosexual agenda. Much of his talk seems to be lifted directly from anti-gay American researchers like Dr. Judith Reisman of Liberty University and the widely discredited Paul Cameron.

Dr. Antonios worked the crowd into a frenzy, shouting that “Africa will become a graveyard for homosexuality!” multiple times.

Evan Hurst, associate director of Truth Wins Out, said:

Evan Hurst (Courtesy of  Truth Wins Out)

Evan Hurst (Courtesy of Truth Wins Out)

“The Religious Right in the United States, having lost the culture war at home, is swimming in dangerous waters abroad, as they cynically play on the fears of people in developing nations, convincing them that their greatest problems lie with infiltration from white, western gay activists.

“Whereas the truth of the matter is that these large, western Christian organizations are playing the same cultural manipulation game they’re projecting onto the gay community. They know they can’t get away with it in the West anymore, so they’ve taken the show on the road, and it could have disastrous results for the health and safety of LGBT individuals in Africa, and for millions of Africans suffering from poverty and lack of economic opportunity.”

Indeed, this is nothing new for Campus Crusade For Christ, as they were the first organization to bring American anti-gay activist Scott Lively to Uganda in 2002, the beginning of the movement which led to Uganda’s infamous “Kill The Gays” bill several years later. Lively is being sued by the Center for Constitutional Rights for his alleged his  ”active participation in the conspiracy to strip away fundamental rights from LGBT persons” in Uganda.

According to researcher and co-founder of Talk2Action.org Bruce Wilson:

“Campus Crusade’s Pamoja 3 conference demonstrates that some of the biggest U.S.-based international evangelical ministries are directly promoting eliminationist anti-gay hate speech in Africa. Also implicated are apostles and prophets of C. Peter Wagner’s New Apostolic Reformation, such as The Call head Lou Engle, and some of the biggest American-based Christian international aid organizations receiving USAID funding.”

Scott Lively (Photo courtesy of TowleRoad.com)

Scott Lively (Photo courtesy of TowleRoad.com)

Grove City College Professor Warren Throckmorton has pointed out that American-led anti-gay groups in Africa “use rhetoric that is disturbingly akin to rhetoric used by Nazis regarding homosexuality,” but these efforts aren’t being led by rogues on the evangelical fringe such as Scott Lively. They represent a significant minority of global evangelicalism, as well as countless U.S. based ministries, large and small, that work closely together in Africa because of a shared ideological vision that includes eliminating homosexuality or, at least, driving LGBT citizens back into the closet.

It’s imperative that evangelicals who want to lay claim to being in the Christian mainstream forcefully repudiate these American and Western instigated efforts to defame and even legislatively annihilate an entire segment of humanity.

Campus Crusades for Christ logoWhile activists like Scott Lively and Paul Cameron are considered fringe among American anti-gay Evangelical activists, Campus Crusade For Christ works within the mainstream, with a budget of half a billion dollars, a presence on 1,600 college campuses, as well as extensive outreach within the U.S. Military.

However, it has become apparent that their message has become increasingly radicalized, especially outside the United States, following the lead of other American entities like Pat Robertson’s ACLJ, which export homophobia to Africa under the guise evangelism and mission work.

United States Secretary Of State John Kerry is in Ethiopia now for the 21st African Union Summit, and it has been reported recently that USAID money may be benefiting African organizations like Dr. Antonios’ United For Life Ethiopia, which are responsible for spreading falsehoods about and fomenting hatred against LGBT people in Africa.

Truth Wins Out strongly encourages Secretary Kerry to use his platform to condemn the actions of these American and African organizations which are working in concert to demonize LGBT people and distract citizens of Africa’s nations from finding solutions to the real problems they face.

Furthermore, Truth Wins Out demands that Campus Crusade For Christ come clean with the American public about their activities abroad, and immediately cease fomenting hatred against LGBT people in Africa, as people’s lives, quite literally, depend on it.

Posted in Africa (Sub Saharan), Faith and religion | Tagged , , , , , , , | 1 Comment

Congo: LGBT activists arrested, beaten, released (update)

This is an update of a preliminary report published May 14, 2013.

Map of the Democratic Republic of Congo shows Bukavu in the far east, near the borders Uganda, Rwanda and Burundi.

Map of the Democratic Republic of Congo shows Bukavu in the far east, near the borders Uganda, Rwanda and Burundi.

Earlier this month, police in the Democratic Republic of Congo arrested two members of the non-governmental organization Rainbow Sunrise Mapambazuko, which works for sexual health and human rights for lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender and intersex (LGBTI) people in Bukavu, DRC. In following up on the account of the incidents, human rights activists with connections to Bukavu were told that the arrests occurred, though some of the specifics remained unclear, including the exact charges and the men’s treatment in custody.

The following account comes from Rainbow Sunrise Mapambazuko, with reports from other sources in brackets:

LGBTI activist Joseph Saidi, 26, was arrested May 4 in Bukavu on charges of promoting homosexuality, then detained for four days, during which time he was tortured and beaten by police, then beaten and raped by fellow inmates while a police investigator looked on.

He was also accused of rape, but police did not pursue that charge for lack of evidence.

[One source said the incident was referred to police because a financial dispute arose after consensual sex and that the rape charge against Saidi was dropped after he paid his sex partner what he had promised.]

Saidi’s colleague, Jeremie Safari, pleaded with local authorities and international human rights activists, seeking Saidi’s release.

Saidi was freed May 8 after paying the arresting officer US$400, but police were offended by things that Safari said while seeking Saidi’s release. As a result, Safari himself was arrested on May 9. [Reportedly, the charge may have been obstructing police activity.]

Safari also was tortured and forced to undergo degrading treatment in prison.
He was released May 10 and is now being treated for injuries he suffered in prison.

The Democratic Republic of Congo does not have a law against homosexual activity, but police often behave as if such a law exists, activists say. In much of Congolese society, violence against LGBTI people is considered acceptable behavior, which police and government officials neither seek to prevent nor to punish.

Saidi, the founder and president of Rainbow Sunrise Mapambazuko, are Safari are currently undergoing medical treatment. Saidi hopes to raise money to travel the 250 miles to Kigali, Rwanda, for a medical scan that his doctor says he needs.

Previously, in December 2012, police surrounded the office of Rainbow Sunrise Mapambazuko in an unsuccessful attempt to arrest Saidi and Safari.  At another time, unidentified armed men visited the homes of Rainbow Sunrise staff members, who since then have moved to undisclosed locations.

Rainbow Sunrise activists say they hope they can change the behavior and attitudes of police, the army and Congolese society in general by correcting misinformation and stereotypes that lead to violence against LGBTI people.

Related articles
Posted in Africa (Sub Saharan), Harassment, Trials / punishments | Tagged , , , , , , , , , | 2 Comments

2 more Moroccans imprisoned for homosexual acts

Agence France-Presse reports:

Temara is located just south of Rabat on the Moroccan coast.

Temara is located just south of Rabat on the Moroccan coast.

Two young Moroccan men were jailed on Monday [May 20]  by a court in Temara for four months for being homosexuals, one of their lawyers told AFP.

The two, aged 20 and 28, were arrested at the beginning of the month at Temara near the capital by police who found them together in a car.

On Monday both men denied the charges.

“We were in the car having a chat, nothing more. We’ve done nothing illegal,” one defendant told the court.

The lawyer said: “We told the judge that the statement signed by the accused contains inexactitudes,” adding that he would discuss with the men’s families on Tuesday [May 21] whether to appeal.

The police version of the incident is different. Police said the two men were arrested after a routine police patrol found them engaging in sex inside a car.

The police report said the pair had stated: “We met on the Internet and we made ​​an appointment on May 2 at Temara for an intimate encounter.” Police said the sex acts were performed in exchange for money.

Some lawyers said the men’s four-month sentence is “mild,” because of their young age and their lack of a criminal record.

Under Moroccan law, homosexual activity is punishable with prison sentences of six months to three years.

On May 6, two unidentified men were sentenced to three years in prison for violating that law.

Posted in Middle East / North Africa, Trials / punishments | Tagged , , | 1 Comment